{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "revision": "R03",
  "date": "2026-10-17",
  "observed_main_sha": "f2631402a366755b252aee0aab75ffdc30209be5",
  "authorization": {
    "scope": "Creator authorizes a slight local border-area redesign and a useful road where warranted",
    "acceptance": "Concept design authorized; specific refined line, measured parcels, road geometry and foundation acceptance remain review items"
  },
  "creator_decision": {
    "selected_macro_option": "A",
    "path": "docs/southwest-prep/R02/BORDER_DECISION.json",
    "git_blob_sha1": "6c6987db3555376d9c0447817d1aa9e6caacd8c2",
    "publication_ref": "e7428474ff1d4f9179f2fad4a9c2d2ae097428f2",
    "publication_scope": "PR87 head, not observed main"
  },
  "source_options": {
    "path": "production/regions/WestCoast/southwest/SEAM_OPTIONS.json",
    "git_blob_sha1": "32a8155ad3b2148d38c6fb7108f1753f8cd6eb8e",
    "historical_selected_value_on_main": null
  },
  "atlas_source": {
    "path": "web/the-island/development/atlas/atlas.json",
    "git_blob_sha1": "7453855964d86008a2744987ce45d6f21e4c5919",
    "ref": "f2631402a366755b252aee0aab75ffdc30209be5",
    "record_selector": "locations[id].anchor_px"
  },
  "map": {
    "path": "maps/paradise-islands/versions/2026-10-10/paradise-islands-clean.png",
    "size_px": [
      1536,
      1024
    ],
    "git_blob_sha1": "932b008413f88eb7f75edeb0a0c1a71db89e6b81",
    "units": "image pixels, x right/y down",
    "metric_transform": null
  },
  "original_A": {
    "polyline_source_px": [
      [
        198,
        318
      ],
      [
        300,
        326
      ],
      [
        378,
        318
      ],
      [
        440,
        322
      ],
      [
        480,
        316
      ],
      [
        530,
        332
      ]
    ],
    "status": "creator-selected macro baseline retained for comparison"
  },
  "preferred_concept": {
    "id": "A-REFINED-R03",
    "status": "PREFERRED_COORDINATOR_CONCEPT_FOR_REVIEW",
    "polyline_source_px": [
      [
        198,
        318
      ],
      [
        245,
        307
      ],
      [
        285,
        303
      ],
      [
        330,
        299
      ],
      [
        355,
        300
      ],
      [
        378,
        318
      ],
      [
        440,
        322
      ],
      [
        480,
        316
      ],
      [
        530,
        332
      ]
    ],
    "world_polyline_m": null,
    "accepted_exact_boundary": false,
    "rationale": "Make a small northward bow only west of the highway so the arrival/cafe target cluster lies consistently in SW; retain coast endpoints and the original highway/eastern portion. Preserve whole eventual parcels when translating this concept into the authored layout.",
    "unchanged_vertices": [
      [
        378,
        318
      ],
      [
        440,
        322
      ],
      [
        480,
        316
      ],
      [
        530,
        332
      ]
    ],
    "unchanged_west_endpoint": [
      198,
      318
    ],
    "new_vertices_are": "authored concept coordinates, not traced surveyed controls"
  },
  "comparison": {
    "method": "Piecewise-linear vertical difference at identical image x; extrema occur at combined vertices. Trapezoid integration gives the area between the two traces in the image plane.",
    "affected_x_interval_px": [
      198,
      378
    ],
    "largest_vertical_departure_px": 24.333333,
    "largest_vertical_departure_at_x_px": 300,
    "image_change_mask_area_px2": 2933.0,
    "world_distance_m": null,
    "land_area_m2": null,
    "warning": "Pixel departure and image-plane area only; this perspective artwork cannot supply physical distances or land area."
  },
  "story_pin_comparison": [
    {
      "id": "PI-LOC-001",
      "name": "Guest boat reception",
      "anchor_px": [
        283,
        324
      ],
      "placement_status": "Placement proposed",
      "coordinate_precision": "Image-space target zone; not a surveyed parcel",
      "actual_footprint": null,
      "original_A": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "NW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": -0.666667,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 0.664626
      },
      "A_refined": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 20.8,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 20.696774
      },
      "scope_note": "Illustrative target pin, not a confirmed parcel or building position"
    },
    {
      "id": "PI-LOC-002",
      "name": "Sophia\u2019s adaptive villa",
      "anchor_px": [
        332,
        355
      ],
      "placement_status": "Placement proposed",
      "coordinate_precision": "Image-space target zone; not a surveyed parcel",
      "actual_footprint": null,
      "original_A": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 32.282051,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 32.113585
      },
      "A_refined": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 55.92,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 55.875318
      },
      "scope_note": "Illustrative target pin, not a confirmed parcel or building position"
    },
    {
      "id": "PI-LOC-003",
      "name": "Trinity caf\u00e9 / guest social hub",
      "anchor_px": [
        350,
        314
      ],
      "placement_status": "Placement proposed",
      "coordinate_precision": "Image-space target zone; not a surveyed parcel",
      "actual_footprint": null,
      "original_A": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "NW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": -6.871795,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 6.835934
      },
      "A_refined": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 14.2,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 14.106611
      },
      "scope_note": "Illustrative target pin, not a confirmed parcel or building position"
    },
    {
      "id": "PI-LOC-004",
      "name": "Guest exploration circuit",
      "anchor_px": [
        450,
        287
      ],
      "placement_status": "Placement proposed",
      "coordinate_precision": "Image-space target zone; not a surveyed parcel",
      "actual_footprint": null,
      "original_A": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "NW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": -33.5,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 33.129368
      },
      "A_refined": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "NW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": -33.5,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 33.129368
      },
      "scope_note": "Illustrative target pin, not a confirmed parcel or building position"
    },
    {
      "id": "PI-LOC-041",
      "name": "Lena\u2019s villa / journal room",
      "anchor_px": [
        366,
        347
      ],
      "placement_status": "Placement proposed",
      "coordinate_precision": "Image-space target zone; not a surveyed parcel",
      "actual_footprint": null,
      "original_A": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 27.769231,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 27.624315
      },
      "A_refined": {
        "side_of_drawn_line": "SW",
        "vertical_image_difference_px": 38.391304,
        "nearest_polyline_distance_px": 31.38471
      },
      "scope_note": "Conditional Lena-villa framework; does not drive access construction"
    }
  ],
  "optional_access_reservation": {
    "id": "RC-A-01",
    "status": "OPTIONAL_ACCESS_RESERVATION_NOT_A_REQUIRED_NEW_ROAD",
    "source_polyline_px": [
      [
        295,
        334
      ],
      [
        314,
        335
      ],
      [
        334,
        329
      ],
      [
        350,
        326
      ]
    ],
    "world_polyline_m": null,
    "from": {
      "role": "approximate coast/local-road interface",
      "source_px": [
        295,
        334
      ],
      "existing_junction_verified": false
    },
    "to": {
      "role": "proposed shared arrival/cafe forecourt access south of the cafe target",
      "source_px": [
        350,
        326
      ],
      "parcel_or_junction_approved": false
    },
    "topology": "Existing coastal/local network -> short local access branch if needed -> shared arrival/cafe access area; pedestrian branches to arrival, cafe and villa; existing network provides onward Harbor View access.",
    "construction_trigger": "Trace and retain usable existing access first. Build the short branch only if the authored layout proves a missing or unsuitable connection.",
    "design_requirements": [
      "guest walk continuity",
      "slow local/service access",
      "distinct cafe rear/service approach",
      "preserve whole functional parcels",
      "no new highway junction",
      "no continuous border boulevard",
      "no new berth or pier implied",
      "L41 conditional; does not drive access construction"
    ],
    "risks_to_resolve": [
      "existing road geometry and access not surveyed",
      "possible conflict with visible roof/vegetation texture",
      "terrain grades and drainage unknown",
      "actual shore/arrival berth unverified",
      "vehicle turning and guest/service separation untested"
    ]
  },
  "shared_edge_review": {
    "ids": [
      "A-EDGE-01",
      "A-EDGE-02",
      "A-EDGE-03",
      "A-EDGE-04",
      "A-EDGE-05"
    ],
    "production_context": "Interface-specific shared review extents, not a second border or fixed-width buffer; one owner and one canonical source per object",
    "fixed_width_m": null,
    "fixed_width_px": null,
    "closed_parcel_polygons": null
  },
  "validation": {
    "seam_source_blob_match": "pass",
    "atlas_source_blob_match": "pass",
    "baseline_A_matches_creator_record": "pass",
    "coast_endpoints_and_eastern_A_unchanged": "pass",
    "arrival_and_cafe_pins_both_SW_in_concept": "pass",
    "Harbor_View_pin_remains_NW": "pass",
    "canonical_geo_modified": false,
    "metric_values_created": false,
    "parcel_fit": "not_tested",
    "road_requirement": "pending_existing_access_trace",
    "engine_acceptance": "not_tested"
  }
}
