# Crown Landmark coordination R01 — independent QA

**Reviewed:** 16 October 2026  
**Scope:** coordination documents, dimension transcription, source preservation, reference links and release claims. This is not a shell, architectural-code, furnished-clearance or Unreal acceptance review.

## Outcome

The coordination layer accurately describes the deliverable as a reference handoff and proposed work plan. It does not claim that the review rig is a completed shell, that the planning zones are finished rooms, or that the building has passed engine tests. No unsupported design or dimension approval was found.

**Coordination review passed after the focused corrections below.** Both machine-readable source references now resolve, their derivations are explicit, and the CSV matches the corrected JSON metadata. The dimension task is now marked prepared. No open coordination-content blocker remains in this review. Final archive/manifest verification is the release coordinator's separate final step and was outside this review while those files were being assembled.

## Findings

| ID | Original severity | Exact location | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-01 | Medium — source traceability | `BUILDING_DIMENSIONS.json` → `measurement_metadata["/envelope/crown_height"].source`; corresponding `DIMENSION_REGISTER.csv` row | **Closed.** Source now uses the valid `#/crown_zone_m` pointer. The 240 − 216 = 24 m derivation is in `meaning`. Focused recheck resolved the source and confirmed CSV source/meaning parity; value unchanged. |
| QA-02 | Medium — source traceability | `BUILDING_DIMENSIONS.json` → `measurement_metadata["/core_and_structure/1/count"].source`; corresponding `DIMENSION_REGISTER.csv` row | **Closed.** Source now uses the valid `#/rooms` pointer. `meaning` explains the two repeated stair identities RM090/RM091 and states that continuity remains unverified. Focused recheck resolved the source and confirmed CSV source/meaning parity; value unchanged. |
| QA-03 | Low — release status | `TASK_BOARD.csv` → `CK-003` | **Closed.** Status is now `prepared`, naming the completed dimensions, brief and register. It does not promote dimensions to approved or measured. |

The passenger-lift count of three is a valid interpretation of the source text “Three passenger shafts”; it is not a direct numeric transcription. Its text-source citation is legitimate. Unknown dimensions represented as blank cells in the CSV correspond to JSON `null`, not zero.

## Checks completed

- Compared every extracted source file to the corresponding uploaded ZIP entry: **32 EXT files + 89 INT files = 121 unchanged files**. These counts include source documentation/manifests; they are separate from the source manifests' 22 EXT image and 88 INT payload entries.
- Parsed the asset brief, dimensions and spatial preflight JSON successfully.
- Checked **1,467 dimension-register rows** against their JSON pointers and values: **1,117 numeric values and 350 unresolved/null values**, with CSV blank interpreted as null. No value mismatch found.
- Checked direct source JSON references and numeric values. Apart from the two malformed fragments above, references resolved; the three-lift text interpretation was identified and supported.
- Confirmed all 81 room-zone IDs are retained in both the brief and dimension contract. Brief level/room links point into the dimension contract rather than duplicating elevations.
- Checked referenced local source/drawing paths in the brief and dimensions, plus local links in `START_HERE.md`, `QUIK_WORK_ORDER.md` and `SHELL_EVIDENCE.md`: no missing referenced files found.
- Checked every measurement status and approval field: statuses are proposed or unresolved, approvals remain null, and unresolved records have an owner and resolution task.
- Read the current bundled Building R05 guide/consolidated workflow. The cover correctly overrides the historical R02 process instruction without rewriting archived source files.
- Reviewed the spatial preflight claims and limitations. It checks source planning rectangles and opening endpoints; it explicitly does not certify actual room circulation, usable shell fit, furniture clearance or engine behavior. The 68 × 54 m tower-base comparison is not presented as the upper-floor shell.
- Read the final root `README.md`, `COORDINATION/LOCAL_DOT_TASK.md` and `COORDINATION/SPATIAL_REVIEW/README.md`. They correctly state that no workstation model execution occurred, the local-dot assignment is prepared rather than sent, and the OBJ is a review rig rather than a completed shell. The modeling/engine gates remain open.

## Remaining production gates — correctly open

These are future acceptance requirements, not reasons to conceal the useful reference handoff:

1. Identify or author the actual Crown Landmark candidate shell, with editable source, units and immutable revision. The scoped repository search does not prove that no unpushed workstation model exists.
2. Resolve upper-floor taper/rib fit, atrium/gallery headroom and continuous lift/stair/service access in that shell.
3. Record selected playable scope, usable furnished dimensions and the actual player/camera envelope.
4. Establish placement/parcel/orientation before accepting calibrated window views.
5. Produce and review the required model, drawing and engine evidence before using shell-approved, interior-approved or engine-ready status.

The proposed handoff remains useful to Quik because controlling references, source revisions, proposed values, unresolved items, owners and required return evidence are explicit. A recorded reference-handoff release must not be represented as completion of these production gates.
