{
  "id": "CK-RUN-R01-INDEPENDENT-REVIEW",
  "recorded_at": "2026-10-17T01:03:14-04:00",
  "reviewer": {
    "agent": "release_review",
    "model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "role": "Independent read-only reviewer"
  },
  "verdict": "PASS_FOR_PROPOSED_DESIGN_REVIEW_NOT_BUILD_READY",
  "reviewed_sources": {
    "split": "30c2423b92ef008ab725f938f04d90a3926223baaff899a92c9f6e95bcfedc8c",
    "terrace": "c228f3181b490a9d2986e305232af50f20ed5d36fda6216f3b0533b86433a736"
  },
  "ready_buffer": 0,
  "checks": {
    "split": [
      "One enclosed H1 bridge; unequal blades; paired 4.2 x 3.2 m portals aligned at z=88 m.",
      "19 prop AABBs contained; sampled horizontal route clearances exceed proposed half-width.",
      "68 derived files;14 primary PDF pages;9 saved neutral views;clean keyed plans inspected."
    ],
    "terrace": [
      "L00 lobby, studio, lounge and outdoor thresholds form a bounded connected slice.",
      "Independent 2 cm route sampling after bath correction finds no furniture/partition infringement of proposed 0.55 m envelope; bath minimum 0.60 m.",
      "69 derived files;14 primary PDF pages;13 saved neutral views;clean studio plan includes low shower-tray footprint."
    ],
    "materials": [
      "13 PBR definitions,24 prop specifications and all31 asset-family mappings reviewed.",
      "Material-only writer uses bpy.data.libraries.write with only created material datablocks; no save_as_mainfile. Final 12-file material manifest verified; PASS AS PROPOSED DATA/SCRIPT STARTER."
    ]
  },
  "cleared_defects": [
    "Split material keys, left roof datum and ground side-door aprons.",
    "Terrace core containment, duplicate top surfaces and bath vanity/route clearance.",
    "Primary blueprint label overlaps and omitted low furnishing silhouettes.",
    "Neutral exterior framing and renderer near-plane clipping."
  ],
  "remaining_gates": [
    "Split ground-to-gallery lift/stair remains a solid proxy/reservation; no operating vertical route.",
    "Creator H1 and scale selection; final site frame, placement, grade and world view remain unset.",
    "Faceted exterior blockout requires organic facade, arch, fin and glazing reconciliation.",
    "Door operation, final material assignment, prop meshes, collision/player/camera/navigation/performance and actual engine import remain unverified.",
    "Blender and Unreal were not executed; no BLEND or GLB release is claimed."
  ],
  "limits": "Review of proposed local-space candidates; static/finitely sampled geometry checks do not certify runtime behavior, egress or final acceptance."
}
