# Silhouette comparison: C03_r9 vs R06 references

**Approximate guide, not pass/fail.** References are perspective AI concept renders; front/rear/left/right model renders are orthographic and the elevated ones use a different camera. Silhouettes are height-normalised and centred before scoring, which removes scale/framing differences but not perspective. Percentages are model vs reference silhouette width at the same fraction of height; z values assume the silhouette is 240 m tall (orthographic views only). Look at the sheets before acting.

| pair | IoU normalised | IoU raw | mean abs span diff (frac of height) |
|---|---|---|---|
| front | 0.898 | 0.767 | 0.023 |
| front_master (alt) | 0.795 | 0.742 | 0.072 |
| rear | 0.811 | 0.663 | 0.082 |
| rear_b02 (alt) | 0.870 | 0.839 | 0.041 |
| left_b02 | 0.641 | 0.582 | 0.065 |
| left_obl (alt) | 0.715 | 0.630 | 0.078 |
| right_b02 | 0.587 | 0.595 | 0.069 |
| right_obl (alt) | 0.716 | 0.649 | 0.075 |
| elevated_05 | 0.796 | 0.760 | 0.046 |
| elevated_08 (alt) | 0.819 | 0.741 | 0.074 |
| elevated_rear_06 (alt) | 0.812 | 0.737 | 0.036 |

## front (model `front` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_01_Front.png`)
IoU 0.898 normalised, 0.767 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.67, model 0.67.
- model 10% narrower than reference at z~40-70 m, both sides (span 0.50 vs 0.56 of height; filled width -11%)
- model 24% wider than reference at z~0-10 m, both sides (span 0.60 vs 0.49 of height; filled width +24%)
- model 36% wider than reference at z~220-240 m, both sides (span 0.18 vs 0.13 of height; filled width +58%)
- model 16% narrower than reference at z~80-90 m, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.49 of height; filled width -17%)
- model 12% narrower than reference at z~30-40 m, both sides (span 0.54 vs 0.61 of height; filled width -12%)

## front_master (model `front` vs `refs/01_Master/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_Master_Tall.jpeg`) - alternate reference
IoU 0.795 normalised, 0.742 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.66, model 0.67.
- model 110% wider than reference at z~0-20 m, left edge (span 0.60 vs 0.28 of height; filled width +117%)
- model 84% wider than reference at z~210-240 m, both sides (span 0.19 vs 0.10 of height; filled width +61%)
- model 16% narrower than reference at z~90-120 m, left edge (span 0.33 vs 0.39 of height; filled width -17%)
- model 13% narrower than reference at z~30-50 m, both sides (span 0.53 vs 0.61 of height; filled width -13%)
- model 16% narrower than reference at z~60-70 m, both sides (span 0.48 vs 0.57 of height; filled width -17%)

## rear (model `rear` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_02_Rear.png`)
IoU 0.811 normalised, 0.663 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.73, model 0.67.
- model 23% narrower than reference at z~60-90 m, both sides (span 0.45 vs 0.58 of height; filled width -24%)
- model 19% narrower than reference at z~30-60 m, both sides (span 0.52 vs 0.64 of height; filled width -19%)
- model 18% narrower than reference at z~90-120 m, both sides (span 0.33 vs 0.40 of height; filled width -19%)
- model 12% narrower than reference at z~10-30 m, both sides (span 0.58 vs 0.66 of height; filled width -12%)
- model 17% narrower than reference at z~180-210 m, both sides (span 0.22 vs 0.26 of height; filled width -16%)

## rear_b02 (model `rear` vs `refs/02_OverviewBoards/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_B02_Elevations_Corrected.jpeg` panel rear) - alternate reference
IoU 0.870 normalised, 0.839 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.57, model 0.67.
- model 74% wider than reference at z~210-240 m, both sides (span 0.19 vs 0.11 of height; filled width +57%)
- model 50% wider than reference at z~0-10 m, both sides (span 0.60 vs 0.40 of height; filled width +80%)
- model 14% wider than reference at z~120-150 m, both sides (span 0.25 vs 0.22 of height; filled width +14%)
- model 15% wider than reference at z~150-180 m, both sides (span 0.23 vs 0.20 of height; filled width +15%)
- model 12% wider than reference at z~180-210 m, both sides (span 0.22 vs 0.19 of height; filled width +12%)

## left_b02 (model `left` vs `refs/02_OverviewBoards/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_B02_Elevations_Corrected.jpeg` panel left)
IoU 0.641 normalised, 0.582 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.59, model 0.50.
- model 22% narrower than reference at z~40-70 m, both sides (span 0.35 vs 0.45 of height; filled width -24%)
- model 23% narrower than reference at z~70-100 m, both sides (span 0.31 vs 0.40 of height; filled width -24%)
- model 15% narrower than reference at z~10-40 m, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.49 of height; filled width -16%)
- model 128% wider than reference at z~220-240 m, left edge (span 0.14 vs 0.06 of height; filled width +93%)
- model 17% wider than reference at z~140-170 m, left edge (span 0.23 vs 0.19 of height; filled width +16%)

## left_obl (model `left` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_03_LeftOblique.png`) - alternate reference
IoU 0.715 normalised, 0.630 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.67, model 0.50.
- model 31% narrower than reference at z~10-40 m, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.60 of height; filled width -31%)
- model 31% narrower than reference at z~40-70 m, both sides (span 0.35 vs 0.51 of height; filled width -33%)
- model 26% narrower than reference at z~70-100 m, left edge (span 0.31 vs 0.41 of height; filled width -26%)
- model 159% wider than reference at z~220-240 m, left edge (span 0.14 vs 0.05 of height; filled width +136%)
- model 31% wider than reference at z~0-10 m, both sides (span 0.43 vs 0.33 of height; filled width +41%)

## right_b02 (model `right` vs `refs/02_OverviewBoards/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_B02_Elevations_Corrected.jpeg` panel right)
IoU 0.587 normalised, 0.595 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.64, model 0.50.
- model 21% narrower than reference at z~40-70 m, both sides (span 0.35 vs 0.45 of height; filled width -23%)
- model 22% narrower than reference at z~70-100 m, left edge (span 0.31 vs 0.40 of height; filled width -23%)
- model 15% narrower than reference at z~10-40 m, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.49 of height; filled width -15%)
- model 132% wider than reference at z~220-240 m, right edge (span 0.14 vs 0.06 of height; filled width +94%)
- model 18% wider than reference at z~140-170 m, right edge (span 0.22 vs 0.19 of height; filled width +17%)

## right_obl (model `right` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_04_RightOblique.png`) - alternate reference
IoU 0.716 normalised, 0.649 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.67, model 0.50.
- model 29% narrower than reference at z~10-40 m, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.59 of height; filled width -30%)
- model 30% narrower than reference at z~40-70 m, right edge (span 0.35 vs 0.50 of height; filled width -32%)
- model 24% narrower than reference at z~70-100 m, right edge (span 0.31 vs 0.40 of height; filled width -24%)
- model 54% wider than reference at z~0-10 m, left edge (span 0.43 vs 0.28 of height; filled width +203%)
- model 76% wider than reference at z~220-240 m, both sides (span 0.14 vs 0.08 of height; filled width +65%)

## elevated_05 (model `elevated` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_05_FrontElevated.png`)
IoU 0.796 normalised, 0.760 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.64, model 0.62.
- model 22% narrower than reference at 4-17% height, right edge (span 0.39 vs 0.50 of height; filled width -21%)
- model 13% narrower than reference at 21-33% height, left edge (span 0.50 vs 0.58 of height; filled width -13%)
- model 16% wider than reference at 54-67% height, right edge (span 0.27 vs 0.23 of height; filled width +15%)
- model 46% wider than reference at 92-100% height, both sides (span 0.15 vs 0.10 of height; filled width +71%)
- model 12% wider than reference at 67-79% height, right edge (span 0.22 vs 0.20 of height; filled width +11%)

## elevated_08 (model `elevated` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_08_ThreeQuarter.png`) - alternate reference
IoU 0.819 normalised, 0.741 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.66, model 0.62.
- model 26% narrower than reference at 4-17% height, both sides (span 0.39 vs 0.53 of height; filled width -26%)
- model 11% narrower than reference at 25-38% height, both sides (span 0.47 vs 0.53 of height; filled width -11%)
- model 61% narrower than reference at 0-4% height, right edge (span 0.11 vs 0.28 of height; filled width -60%)
- model 52% wider than reference at 88-100% height, both sides (span 0.16 vs 0.10 of height; filled width +59%)
- model 23% wider than reference at 58-71% height, right edge (span 0.25 vs 0.20 of height; filled width +22%)

## elevated_rear_06 (model `elevated_rear` vs `refs/03_IndividualViews/PI-BLD-0001-V01_CrownLandmark_EXT_R06_06_RearElevated.png`) - alternate reference
IoU 0.812 normalised, 0.737 raw. Silhouette aspect (width/height): reference 0.65, model 0.62.
- model 15% narrower than reference at 25-38% height, both sides (span 0.48 vs 0.57 of height; filled width -15%)
- model 24% narrower than reference at 0-12% height, right edge (span 0.25 vs 0.33 of height; filled width -24%)
- model 11% narrower than reference at 38-50% height, both sides (span 0.41 vs 0.46 of height; filled width -13%)
- model 14% narrower than reference at 83-92% height, both sides (span 0.18 vs 0.21 of height; filled width -12%)
- model 10% wider than reference at 54-58% height, both sides (span 0.30 vs 0.27 of height; filled width +10%)
