[
 {
  "id": 1,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "No UCX_/UBX_/UCP_/USP_ named parts in GLB (162 nodes) or OBJ (162 object records); search of GLB/OBJ/MTL/MODEL_MEASUREMENTS for those prefixes and the word collision finds nothing (only README.md/MODEL_SPEC.json text saying collision is unfinished)",
  "value": "0 collision-named parts"
 },
 {
  "id": 2,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "glTF extras: scene-level asset_id/revision/status/units/source_to_gltf/saved_cameras only; mesh+node extras are only group and review_status=CONCEPT. No extensions (extensionsUsed/Required absent), no collision/walkable/physics property of any kind",
  "value": "10 group values"
 },
 {
  "id": 3,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Nothing distinguishes walkable from decorative parts except part names/groups: Facade grid 62, Podium arcades 43, Ribs and crown 19, Entrance and basins 15, Podium terraces 12, Podium glazing 3, Front atrium 3, Tower glazing 2, Rear authority motif 2, Foundation 1",
  "value": "162 parts"
 },
 {
  "id": 4,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "All 9 materials are opaque PBR (baseColor alpha 1, no alphaMode) and doubleSided=true; glass-like parts (podium_glass 3, blue 8, parapet 4, amber 1, water 6) carry no transparency flag; material names are the only semantic hint",
  "value": "0 BLEND, 9/9 doubleSided"
 },
 {
  "id": 5,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "No node transforms (nodes hold only name/mesh/extras); one triangle-list primitive per mesh; OBJ has 61,556 faces = GLB 61,556 triangles",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 6,
  "section": "1 metadata",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "README.md and MODEL_SPEC.json state engine collision is unfinished and that glazing is an opaque review skin, not a collision assembly",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 7,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Of 162 parts, 105 are closed (every edge shared by exactly 2 triangles after 1e-5 weld) and 57 are open single surfaces",
  "value": "105 closed / 57 open"
 },
 {
  "id": 8,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Open parts: Podium_wall_1/2/3, Cantilever_fascia_1-3, Terrace_N_blue_parapet x3, Terrace_N_coping x3 (non-manifold), Tower_curtainwall_skin, Storey_band_01-36, Crown_glass_R1-6 (1 triangle each), Front_amber_atrium_skin, Entry_glass_canopy",
  "value": "57 parts, 6,778 boundary edges"
 },
 {
  "id": 9,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Closed solids: Foundation, Deck_1/2/3, all 43 Podium arcades incl. Main_entry_clear_18x14, Occupied_roof, Central cap, 6 Ribs, 6 Gold_inner, 26 Mullions, Basin rims/water, canopy edges, rear and front gold tubes",
  "value": "105 parts"
 },
 {
  "id": 10,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "All 105 closed parts have positive signed volume (outward normals); 0 winding-inconsistent edges across all 162 parts; 0 inverted parts",
  "value": "0 inverted"
 },
 {
  "id": 11,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "0 degenerate/zero-area triangles (<1e-8 m2), 0 slivers (<1e-4 m2), 0 unreferenced vertices, 1 connected component per part",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 12,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Duplicate (coincident within 1e-5) vertices: 9 total, all in Terrace_1/2/3_coping (3 each, tube loop first/last point); those 3 parts have 2 non-manifold edges each; no other non-manifold edges",
  "value": "9 dup verts; 3 nonmanifold parts"
 },
 {
  "id": 13,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Thickness: Podium_wall_1/2/3 (16/16/8 tris), Tower skin (8,360 tris), Storey bands, Cantilever_fascia, parapets, Front_amber_atrium_skin, canopy, Crown_glass are zero-thickness single surfaces; Deck slabs 0.59-0.594 m solid, Occupied_roof 0.39 m, Foundation 1.18 m, arcade frames 2.2 m deep solids, ribs solid (min bbox dim 16-35 m)",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 14,
  "section": "2 integrity",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Wall/skin/band/parapet/amber normals face outward (exterior); Cantilever_fascia normals face up (91% nz>0.5); Entry_glass_canopy normals face down (88% nz<-0.5)",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 15,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Up-facing horizontal surfaces >=20 m2 exist only at z = 0.0 (Foundation 19,025 m2), 0.55 (Basin_rim x6), 0.59 (Basin_water x6), 18.0 (Deck_1 15,195 m2), 36.0 (Deck_2 11,121), 54.0 (Deck_3 7,891), 216.0 (Occupied_roof 922 m2)",
  "value": "7 distinct levels"
 },
 {
  "id": 16,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L00 (z0): 80/80 sample points (16 rooms, centre + 4 corners +1.5 m) hit Foundation_160x120 at z=0.0, front-facing",
  "value": "100% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 17,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L03 (z18): 55/55 points (11 rooms) hit Deck_1_top_18m at z=18.0, front-facing",
  "value": "100% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 18,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L01 (z6): 0/55 points have a surface at z=6; first hit is Foundation top z=0.0",
  "value": "0% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 19,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L02 (z12): 0/55 points have a surface at z=12; first hit is Foundation top z=0.0",
  "value": "0% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 20,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L25 (z126): 0/75 points have a surface; first hit is Deck_3_top_54m at z=54.0 (72 m below)",
  "value": "0% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 21,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "L26 (z130.5): 0/85 points have a surface; first hit is Deck_3_top_54m at z=54.0 (76.5 m below)",
  "value": "0% supported"
 },
 {
  "id": 22,
  "section": "3 walkable",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "No tower slabs exist between z=54 and z=216. Occupied_roof_top_216m is a 36 x 26 m plate whose edge (x=+-18) sits about 2.4 m inside the skin at y=0 (skin hit at x~20.5 from above); rays dropped into that gap fall to Deck_3 at z=54",
  "value": "~2.4 m perimeter gap"
 },
 {
  "id": 23,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Interior walls do not exist in the GLB: the only vertical surfaces are Podium_wall_1/2/3 (perimeter rings), Tower skin, storey bands, parapets, mullions and arcade frames. Of 102 layout doors, rays at +1.0 and +1.7 m above level (+-6 m along the passage) hit a part for exactly 1 door (L00-D001 portal 8 x 4.5 m); the other 101 meet no exported geometry",
  "value": "1/102"
 },
 {
  "id": 24,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Main_entry_clear_18x14 is a closed solid arch FRAME (1.5 m thick, 2.2 m deep, y -56.1..-53.9, x +-10.5, z 0..15.5) with a real through-opening: 0.25 m ray grid at z=1.0 and 1.7 passes for x -8.75..8.75 (~18 m) and at x=0 is free from z=0.05 to ~13.8-14.0 m",
  "value": "frame opening ~18 x 14 m"
 },
 {
  "id": 25,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Behind the frame, Podium_wall_1 is a continuous zero-thickness wall at y=-52.4 (bay front, x -39.2..27.2, z 0.2..17.35), 1.5 m behind the frame rear face. Of 3,726 rays in |x|<=8.5, z<=13.5, 3,657 hit Podium_wall_1 (front-facing, y=-52.4); the 69 that do not are all in the z=0.05 row, passing through a 0.2 m slit between Foundation top (z=0) and wall bottom (z=0.2). Clear gap through the wall at 1.0 and 1.7 m height = 0",
  "value": "0 m wide x 0 m high; 0.2 m slit"
 },
 {
  "id": 26,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "The entry is a marker/frame, not a hole in the wall: no opening is cut in Podium_wall_1 (8-vertex ring, 16 triangles); portal door L00-D001 (y=-52, 8 m wide) is fully blocked (34/34 rays hit Podium_wall_1)",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 27,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "All 43 arcade frames (42 T*_arch + Main entry) have an open frame hole (clear widths 10.5-18 m), but for 43/43 every ray through the hole is stopped by a further part: Podium_wall_1/2/3 behind 34 of them (incl. Main entry), ribs/amber skin/gold tube behind 9; 0 through-paths",
  "value": "0/43 through-paths"
 },
 {
  "id": 28,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "T1_front_arch_1 and _6: frame clear run 12.5 m; all rays through the frame hit Podium_wall_1 about 3 m beyond the outer face",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 29,
  "section": "4 openings",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Podium walls hover: Wall_1 z 0.2-17.35 (Deck_1 soffit 17.4), Wall_2 18.2-35.35 (Deck_1 top 18.0, Deck_2 soffit 35.4), Wall_3 36.2-53.35 (Deck_3 soffit 53.4): 0.2 m gap at base and 0.05 m at top of every wall",
  "value": "0.2 m / 0.05 m"
 },
 {
  "id": 30,
  "section": "5 interpenetration",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Closed-solid vs closed-solid overlap pairs (area>0.01 m2): 45, all involving a Rib or Basin; Deck_1/2/3 vs Rib_R1-6 up to 71.6 m2 slice area; Basin_rim/Basin_water vs Rib up to 40.1 m2; T1/T2 arcades vs Rib up to 11.9 m2; no arcade-vs-arcade, deck-vs-arcade or deck-vs-deck overlap",
  "value": "45 pairs"
 },
 {
  "id": 31,
  "section": "5 interpenetration",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Shell crossing solid: 20 pairs; Podium_wall_1 crosses Rib_R3/R4 (14.0 m of wall line inside rib at z=16.5), R1/R2 (9.2 m), R5/R6 (3.6 m); Podium_wall_2 crosses Rib_R1 (7.1 m); Tower skin crosses Rib_R1/R2 over 118 slices (4.5 m), R5/R6 129 slices; Podium_wall_1 also crosses T1_front_arch_1 (2.2 m) and Basin_rim_R1/R2 (2.0 m)",
  "value": "20 pairs"
 },
 {
  "id": 32,
  "section": "5 interpenetration",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "No shell-vs-shell line crossings among scoped parts; walls do not overlap decks/fascias; touching only: Deck_3 top z=54 = skin base z=54, arcade bases = deck tops",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 33,
  "section": "5 interpenetration",
  "label": "measured",
  "finding": "Sampling: 1 m z-step plus extra levels (249 slices); volumes are rough trapezoid estimates and maxima may be under-estimated between samples",
  "value": ""
 },
 {
  "id": 34,
  "section": "6 interpretation",
  "label": "interpreted",
  "finding": "Complex-as-simple: all 61,556 triangles of 162 parts become collision. Floors exist only at z=0,18,36,54 (+216 roof); L01/L02 rooms would have no floor (fall to z=0) and L25/L26 none (fall 72-76.5 m to Deck_3); the main entry would be blocked by Podium_wall_1; zero-thickness walls/skin are front-facing from outside only, so blocking from inside depends on the engine double-sided setting",
  "value": "untested"
 },
 {
  "id": 35,
  "section": "6 interpretation",
  "label": "interpreted",
  "finding": "Auto convex decomposition: closed solids (decks, ribs) decompose plausibly; arcade/entry frames get convex approximations (hull of Main_entry_clear_18x14 = 605 m3 vs 133 m3 solid, arcades 3.8-4.7x, so the frame hole would likely be filled); open zero-thickness shells give a degenerate or solid-block result (Podium_wall hull volumes 157,025 / 99,641 / 47,334 m3 for 6,737 / 5,502 / 3,739 m2 of surface); Tower skin likewise",
  "value": "untested"
 },
 {
  "id": 36,
  "section": "7 not testable",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "finding": "Actual engine collision result (complex vs simple, auto-convex hulls, backface/double-sided behaviour, hull count, cook success)",
  "value": "needs engine"
 },
 {
  "id": 37,
  "section": "7 not testable",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "finding": "Character capsule step/slope behaviour; effect of 0.05-0.2 m gaps vs capsule radius; trace channels/presets",
  "value": "needs engine"
 },
 {
  "id": 38,
  "section": "7 not testable",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "finding": "Importer reaction to the 9 duplicate vertices/coping non-manifold edges; self-intersection inside a single part was not measured",
  "value": "not measured"
 },
 {
  "id": 39,
  "section": "7 not testable",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "finding": "Physics material, nav-mesh/walkable-slope generation, LOD collision",
  "value": "no data in files"
 }
]