[
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L00",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L00 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L01",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L01 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L02",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L02 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L03",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L03 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L25",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L25 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.count.L26",
  "topic": "count",
  "label": "proposed",
  "item": "L26 stairs / passenger-lift door records / service reserve rooms",
  "value": "stairs=2 (req 2); passenger lift door records=3 in 1 shaft room (req 3 lifts); service reserve rooms=1 (req 1)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "passenger lifts are ONE room 'Three passenger lift shafts' 12x4.8 m; 3 is inferred from name + 3 lift door records (x=-4,0,4) + notes + brief '4 x 4.8 m planning cells'"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.stack_adjacent",
  "topic": "continuity",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "max |dx,dy,dw,dd| for 5 core rooms across L00-L01, L01-L02, L02-L03, L25-L26 (and L03-L25)",
  "value": 0,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "all footprints identical on all six laid-out levels; IoU=1.0 each pair"
 },
 {
  "id": "B2.stack_L03_L25",
  "topic": "continuity",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "item": "continuity through floors L04-L24 (z=24..120)",
  "value": "NOT EVIDENCED",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "no rooms/doors/cameras exist for 39 of 45 floors; identical L03 and L25 footprints show a straight stack is CONSISTENT with, not evidence of, continuity. Brief says 'interpolate through intervening floors' = a proposal only"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.core_overlap",
  "topic": "conflict",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "area overlaps between core rooms 090-094 and any other room on same level (all 6 levels)",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "m2",
  "note": "edge contact only is not overlap"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.door_not_on_shared_edge",
  "topic": "conflict",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "door records on L00-L03,L25,L26 whose segment is not on the shared edge of from_room/to_room rectangles",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.door_through_core_interior",
  "topic": "conflict",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "door segments crossing the interior of a core footprint",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.door_unconnected_touching_core",
  "topic": "conflict",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "doors touching a core footprint where neither from_room nor to_room is a core room",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.swing_into_unconnected_core",
  "topic": "conflict",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED swing = full disc of radius clear width)",
  "item": "hinged doors whose assumed swing disc intrudes into a core room that is neither from_room nor to_room",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "swing radius/hinge side/direction not in data"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stairdoor.L00-D084",
  "topic": "stair door",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L00-D084 (same on all six levels) 1.5 x 2.7 m at (-18.0,0.0) axis y into L00-RM090 (x -18..-10, y -8..6)",
  "value": "door y-span -0.75..0.75; distance to stair -y end 8.00, +y end 6.00; offset from stair centre-line 1.00",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "door is on the stair's outer long side at mid-length, not at an end"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stairdoor.L00-D085",
  "topic": "stair door",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L00-D085 (same on all six levels) 1.5 x 2.7 m at (18.0,0.0) axis y into L00-RM091 (x 10..18, y -8..6)",
  "value": "door y-span -0.75..0.75; distance to stair -y end 8.00, +y end 6.00; offset from stair centre-line 1.00",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "door is on the stair's outer long side at mid-length, not at an end"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.levels",
  "topic": "rise",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "slab z list (EXT R06 DesignTargets: 9 podium + 36 tower slabs)",
  "value": "45 slabs; index of z=18 is 3, z=126 is 25, z=130.5 is 26",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "level index = slab index is interpreted; matches layout z_m for all six levels"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.gap",
  "topic": "rise",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "item": "L03 (z=18) -> L25 (z=126)",
  "value": "108 m = 6 rises of 6.0 m (L03..L09, to z=54) + 16 rises of 4.5 m (L09..L25); 21 unlaid-out levels L04..L24",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "NO layout for these floors: continuity of lifts/stairs/service through floors 4-24 is NOT evidenced"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.total_rise",
  "topic": "rise",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L00->L03 / L03->L25 / L25->L26 / L00->L26",
  "value": "18.0 / 108.0 / 4.5 / 130.5",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L00",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L00 floor-to-floor to next slab 6.0 m vs core clear_height_m 5.4",
  "value": 0.6,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L01",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L01 floor-to-floor to next slab 6.0 m vs core clear_height_m 5.4",
  "value": 0.6,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L02",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L02 floor-to-floor to next slab 6.0 m vs core clear_height_m 5.4",
  "value": 0.6,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L03",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L03 floor-to-floor to next slab 6.0 m vs core clear_height_m 5.4",
  "value": 0.6,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L25",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L25 floor-to-floor to next slab 4.5 m vs core clear_height_m 3.6",
  "value": 0.9,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.f2f.L26",
  "topic": "clear height",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L26 floor-to-floor to next slab 4.5 m vs core clear_height_m 3.6",
  "value": 0.9,
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "difference = slab+ceiling build-up (interpreted). Core clear height is LESS than one rise, so stairs/shafts need the upper slab open (planning OBJ omits stair/shaft plates)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.proposed_riser.6.0",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "measured (arithmetic on proposed brief/MD06)",
  "item": "rise 6.0 m / 36 risers (1.8 m clear, 0.30 m tread, two flights)",
  "value": 0.1667,
  "unit": "m per riser",
  "note": "18 risers/flight if two equal flights (interpreted); treads/landing depth not given"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.proposed_riser.4.5",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "measured (arithmetic on proposed brief/MD06)",
  "item": "rise 4.5 m / 28 risers (1.8 m clear, 0.30 m tread, two flights)",
  "value": 0.1607,
  "unit": "m per riser",
  "note": "14 risers/flight if two equal flights (interpreted); treads/landing depth not given"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stair_totals",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "measured (arithmetic on proposed)",
  "item": "risers needed along proposed 36 / 28 counts",
  "value": "L00->L03: 3x36=108; L03->L25: 6x36+16x28=664; L25->L26: 28",
  "unit": "risers",
  "note": "only the six laid-out rises are in the layout; the 21 unlaid-out floors are arithmetic on target slab z"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stair_run_proposed",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED treads per flight = risers-1)",
  "item": "going per flight at proposed 0.30 m tread",
  "value": "18 risers->17 treads=5.10 m; 14 risers->13 treads=3.90 m",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "tread count/landing depth not in data"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.headroom_sweep",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED 2.0 m headroom; sweep 1.9-2.2)",
  "item": "mid-landing headroom to upper soffit",
  "value": "6.0 m rise: 2.40 m (ok at 2.0); 4.5 m rise: 1.35 m (BELOW 2.0 for every H in 1.9-2.2 unless upper slab is open above mid-landing)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "L25/L26 clear 3.6 vs 4.5 rise; planning OBJ leaves stair zones open (no floor plate), which would remove the issue - not modelled"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stairdoor_flight",
  "topic": "stair door",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED flight placement)",
  "item": "D084/D085 door span (y -0.75..0.75) vs an assumed flight run in stair y -8..6",
  "value": "10 of 24 sweep combos overlap a flight; overlaps occur for flight anchored at +y end (18-riser flight spans y -0.9..4.2 at 1.8 m landing)",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "real stair placement unknown - a risk, not a measured clash"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.stair_orientation",
  "topic": "stair",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED)",
  "item": "8.0 m X vs 14.0 m Y stair room",
  "value": "two-flight 18-riser run needs 8.1-8.7 m plan length at assumed 1.2-1.8 m landings > 8.0 m; fits 14 m. Width: 2x1.8 = 3.6 m of 8.0 m",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.missing",
  "topic": "missing",
  "label": "not_testable",
  "item": "lift pit/overrun/machine room/speed, cab door swing, stair landing depth/handrail/headroom geometry, service-lift cab size, fire lobby/refuge",
  "value": "NOT IN DATA",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "only: cabin target 2.8x3.2x2.7 m (MD04), cell 4x4.8, lift door 1.5x2.4, service door 1.8x2.6, service shaft 4x5.2 (MD05), stair 1.8 clear/0.30 tread/36 or 28 risers (MD06)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.cab_in_cell",
  "topic": "lift",
  "label": "measured (arithmetic on proposed)",
  "item": "cab 2.8x3.2 in 4x4.8 cell",
  "value": "side clearance 0.6 each, depth spare 1.6",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.lift_door_vs_cab",
  "topic": "lift",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "lift door clear 1.5x2.4 vs cab 2.8x2.7",
  "value": "door/cab width = 0.536; door 0.30 m lower than cab height",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.lift_landing",
  "topic": "lift",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "lift hall RM080 y -16..-8 in front of door line y=-8",
  "value": "8.0 m landing depth vs cab depth 3.2",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.lift_doors_x",
  "topic": "lift",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "passenger lift door centres L00 [('L00-D086', -4), ('L00-D087', 0), ('L00-D088', 4)] vs cell centres -4,0,4",
  "value": "door edge to cell wall 1.25 m; clear between adjacent door edges 2.5 m",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.service_door",
  "topic": "lift",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "D090 (8,2) 1.8 wide vs service shaft x 6..10 (notes/MD05)",
  "value": "edge margin 1.1 m each side; room RM093 is x -10..10 (20 x 5.2): 16 m beyond the 4 m shaft is MEP reserve (interpreted)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B3.service_separation",
  "topic": "service",
  "label": "interpreted",
  "item": "RM093 (y -3.2..2) shares the y=-3.2 edge with passenger shaft room RM092 over x -6..6 (12 m)",
  "value": "back-to-back, no door between; service lift has no door to the lift hall; route RM094 -> D091 (8,6) -> cross corridor RM083",
  "unit": "",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "id": "B5.capsule",
  "topic": "capsule",
  "label": "interpreted (ASSUMED 0.6-1.0 m diameter)",
  "item": "lift door records: 1.5 m (18 passenger records) and 1.8 m (6 service records)",
  "value": "side clearance 0.25..0.45 m (1.5 m) / 0.40..0.60 m (1.8 m); all pass by width",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "width only; sill/threshold, door timing, capsule height and step-up ability unknown (riser 0.1607-0.1667 m is proposed-derived)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L00",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L00 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 28.52 m (Podium_wall_1, L00-RM091); rib 38.61 m (Rib_R5 at z=5.4, L00-RM090)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L01",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L01 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 28.52 m (Podium_wall_1, L01-RM091); rib 36.55 m (Rib_R5 at z=11.4, L01-RM090)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L02",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L02 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 28.52 m (Podium_wall_1, L02-RM091); rib 34.45 m (Rib_R5 at z=17.4, L02-RM090)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L03",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L03 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 19.00 m (Podium_wall_2, L03-RM090); rib 31.52 m (Rib_R3 at z=23.4, L03-RM090)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L25",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L25 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 14.10 m (Tower_curtainwall_skin, L25-RM090); rib 18.00 m (Rib_R3 at z=129.6, L25-RM090)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.L26",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "L26 core rooms 090-094 min wall margin / min rib clearance",
  "value": "wall 13.94 m (Tower_curtainwall_skin, L26-RM090); rib 17.42 m (Rib_R4 at z=134.1, L26-RM091)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "positive = inside / clear"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.fit.worst",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "overall minimum wall margin / rib clearance, core rooms 090-094",
  "value": "wall 13.937 m (L26-RM090); rib 17.422 m (L26-RM091 vs Rib_R4)",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "max |diff| vs published C02_FIT_COVERAGE wall_margin: 0.000 m (n=30)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.extrapolated",
  "topic": "shell fit",
  "label": "interpreted",
  "item": "L03 core footprints straight-extruded to each slab z=18..126 vs C02 wall/skin",
  "value": "min margin 12.0 m at L06 z=36 (Podium_wall_3, rooms 090); all margins >=0: True",
  "unit": "m",
  "note": "shows the C02 skin does not obstruct a straight stack; says nothing about structure/MEP/slabs (not modelled in C02)"
 },
 {
  "id": "B4.c02_core_geometry",
  "topic": "shell",
  "label": "measured",
  "item": "C02 GLB meshes whose name matches core/lift/stair/shaft/slab/floor",
  "value": "none",
  "unit": "",
  "note": "C02 models no core, shaft, stair or slab; fit is plan-vs-skin only"
 }
]