{
  "record_id": "PI-BLD-0002-V01-DESIGN-R01",
  "asset_id": "PI-BLD-0002-V01",
  "asset_name": "Split Complex",
  "revision": "R01",
  "date": "2026-10-16",
  "author": "Codex",
  "purpose": "Select one explicit design hypothesis for a coherent first visual package while preserving the original references and separate creator, dimension, shell, placement and engine gates.",
  "status": "CONCEPT_RECOMMENDATION",
  "spatial_image_state": "CONCEPT",
  "approval": {
    "author_recommendation": "H1 selected for this first design pass",
    "creator_visual_selection": null,
    "enterability_selection": null,
    "dimension_acceptance": null,
    "shell_acceptance": null,
    "placement_acceptance": null,
    "engine_acceptance": null,
    "construction_release": false
  },
  "governance": {
    "creator_decisions": "docs/current-decisions.md section 7, Foundation reset and Spatial image production",
    "protocol_pointer": "production/protocols/current.json",
    "building": "PI-PROT-BUILDING R05",
    "district": "PI-PROT-DISTRICT R04",
    "spatial_imagery": "PI-WF-SPATIAL-IMAGERY R01",
    "existing_dimension_contract": "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/BUILDING_DIMENSIONS.json",
    "dimension_contract_changed": false,
    "foundation_hold": "remains in force; this visual preparation is not world construction authorization",
    "story": "No new canon, owner history, named scene or story-space assignment. Relentless Development remains a production collection proposal for this asset."
  },
  "source_retrieval": {
    "local_workspace": "partial source snapshot; production asset originals were absent and served asset JSON mirrors were empty",
    "asset_records_read_via": "GitHub read-only file access",
    "repository": "215GrandAve/lost-souls",
    "asset_records_commit": "565ec6ab58f6fa08879c682fcb953a2c658b7687",
    "asset_record_git_blobs": {
      "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/README.md": "ee937ee1605582b5e28d2eef2171d247e5fbfb69",
      "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/VISUAL_NOTES.md": "43a77aaefb4ffc2f6648946ef013f520b0461287",
      "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/ASSET_BRIEF.json": "d952aca425679d2f689163abc15b37d1e3bbbae6",
      "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/BUILDING_DIMENSIONS.json": "f268e85e692d7723b39d1c42a0b858f5affb661b",
      "production/assets/buildings/PI-BLD-0002-V01/PREP/R01/README.md": "3ddbc8f7d02c9d741fa2e364d1daf5e4d13c1d43"
    },
    "note": "Git blob identities are not SHA-256 file hashes. Original upload numbering differs from repository reference numbering; subject correspondence does not prove byte identity."
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "S1-CATALOG",
      "input": "22-Crown_Key_Final_Card_Set.zip",
      "archive_sha256": "9094c105c52c274c423ecff89148efe37e3a3938d8138a458698fe9cf274910c",
      "member": "02_Towers_and_Variants_Global_IDs.png",
      "member_sha256": "a84ef3a27eea546ea48c3c154dc4d23c00e0230395dd87b48d221c11e1eb269b",
      "asset_region": "row 1, column 2; labelled PI-BLD-0002-V01 Split Complex",
      "visually_inspected": true,
      "source_nature": "named family catalog concept; sheet says bare architecture, vegetation separate, not to common scale",
      "recommended_authority": "identity, asymmetric overall silhouette, open-gap relationship, one dominant elevated connection and low arcade base",
      "cannot_establish": [
        "metres",
        "floor count",
        "rear geometry",
        "structural feasibility",
        "final placement",
        "creator selection of H1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "S2-GARDEN-RENDER",
      "input": "25-Twin-Blade-Towers-and-Garden-Bridge-4.png",
      "sha256": "46fa82b0bfc1f09a41240d11333d4e54aa1a0f318b6c3fbb0e8a56584395563d",
      "repository_subject_counterpart": "production/districts/D02-CrownKey/references/26-Twin-Blade-Towers-and-Garden-Bridge-4.png",
      "counterpart_byte_identity_verified": false,
      "visually_inspected": true,
      "source_nature": "cropped perspective location concept",
      "recommended_authority": "blue curved glazing, warm ivory blade finishes, inner terraces, amber interiors, planted bridge atmosphere and junction detail vocabulary",
      "cannot_establish": [
        "tower massing ratio",
        "complete podium",
        "one versus two accepted playable bridge levels",
        "pool or garden gameplay",
        "actual city background",
        "metres"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "S3-AMBER-ENTRANCE",
      "input": "28-Crown-Landmark-Amber-Atrium-Entrance-1.png",
      "sha256": "df1724977e23518c4afc383d43b1ecfb00026a0da45a3694727d9e9a0504e37f",
      "visually_inspected": true,
      "source_nature": "Crown Landmark entrance concept for another asset",
      "recommended_authority": "material finish, amber light, glazing depth, planting integration and overall visual craft benchmark only",
      "cannot_establish": [
        "Split Complex footprint",
        "Split Complex entrance shape",
        "a Landmark crown or central atrium",
        "room dimensions",
        "room program",
        "placement"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "S4-PRIOR-CONCEPT",
      "input": "docs/crown-key-production/R01/codex-inputs/split-complex-concept-a-r01.png",
      "sha256": "4a41bac2ad6e86f4e8e133fc5e3a8fb9f027239eedaa30924bed7e5a3e50eca1",
      "visually_inspected": true,
      "source_nature": "previous generated CONCEPT A / NOT TO SCALE study",
      "recommended_authority": "comparison and visual continuity only; no independent authority over original art",
      "cannot_establish": [
        "accepted geometry",
        "measured base or bridge",
        "floor count",
        "correct planting quantity",
        "creator approval"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "S5-REFERENCE-REVIEW",
      "input": "docs/crown-key-production/R01/codex-inputs/SPLIT_REFERENCE_REVIEW.md",
      "sha256": "7058ab38d21a685c0b78874d9c1e4819b4ecf170c2f2420c2dd1c24c6290adfd",
      "source_nature": "previous source-conflict register and Candidate A brief",
      "recommended_authority": "history of the unresolved conflict; H1 now makes a bounded author recommendation without rewriting that record"
    }
  ],
  "observations": [
    {
      "id": "O1",
      "source": "S1-CATALOG",
      "statement": "The left tower is visibly shorter and thinner; the right is taller and wider. Their blade profiles differ."
    },
    {
      "id": "O2",
      "source": "S1-CATALOG",
      "statement": "The left blade has a wrapping ivory ribbon, with a lower stepped outer shoulder; the right has a high pointed sail crest and a long sweeping outer edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "O3",
      "source": "S1-CATALOG",
      "statement": "A large vertical open slot separates the towers, crossed by one visually dominant slim arched bridge band above a low arcade base."
    },
    {
      "id": "O4",
      "source": "S2-GARDEN-RENDER",
      "statement": "The close render shows an open planted upper span with pool and shade elements, plus a lower arched, partly enclosed span. It is cropped and does not resolve the complete base."
    },
    {
      "id": "O5",
      "source": "S2-GARDEN-RENDER",
      "statement": "Curved glazed balconies face the gap; the left roof is scooped and planted while the right blade is sharper. The towers appear more similarly substantial in this view."
    },
    {
      "id": "O6",
      "source": "S3-AMBER-ENTRANCE",
      "statement": "Warm ivory structure, deep blue glazing, amber interior light and integrated planting provide a finish benchmark. The central crown portal belongs to Crown Landmark."
    },
    {
      "id": "O7",
      "source": "S4-PRIOR-CONCEPT",
      "statement": "The prior generated study retains the asymmetric pair and one high connection, but its expanded base, bridge bulk, planting and apparent floor bands are generated interpretations."
    }
  ],
  "interpretations": [
    {
      "id": "I1",
      "basis": [
        "O1",
        "O2",
        "O3"
      ],
      "statement": "The named catalog card is the strongest identity reference for a complete Split Complex silhouette; the close render is stronger for appearance and local detail."
    },
    {
      "id": "I2",
      "basis": [
        "O3",
        "O4"
      ],
      "statement": "A garden above a warm glazed arched connector is a useful shared design theme, but the sources do not prove one identical bridge topology."
    },
    {
      "id": "I3",
      "basis": [
        "O1",
        "O5"
      ],
      "statement": "The cropped perspective cannot justify replacing the card's hierarchy with near-equal towers. No image-derived height ratio is adopted."
    }
  ],
  "selected_design_hypothesis": {
    "id": "H1",
    "label": "Catalog-led asymmetric blades with one planted-roof bridge gallery",
    "selection_status": "RECOMMENDED_BY_CODEX_FOR_FIRST_DESIGN_PASS",
    "creator_approved": false,
    "new_proposal": "Retain the card's massing and one dominant bridge silhouette. Develop one enclosed crossing gallery inside a compact ivory bridge body, with a planted nonplayable roof and an arched soffit/haunch. Both tower landings meet one proposed crossing datum. The planted roof is not a second public bridge deck.",
    "reason": "This preserves the issued identity reference while carrying the close render's garden, glazing and amber-light character into a bounded route. It avoids committing to the conflicting render's separate upper amenity deck, pool and second circulation system.",
    "bridge_level_count": "one candidate accessible crossing level; exact elevation and floor IDs unset",
    "bridge_roof": "scenic planting only in R01; maintenance access deferred, no public roof route",
    "bridge_floor": "level crossing between landing thresholds; the visible arch is a soffit/haunch expression, not an arched walking floor",
    "bridge_attachment": "short recessed landing vestibule at each inner tower face; uninterrupted clear route from core landing to gallery; no balcony rail or fin crossing a threshold",
    "bridge_structure": "bearing, span system, support thickness, movement allowance and structural role of fins remain unresolved",
    "podium": "one low shared arcade ribbon at the tower feet, with a generous open central ground passage and separate lobby thresholds; no enclosed mall",
    "orientation": "For concept comparison only, front means the open-gap catalog side; left/right follow a viewer facing that side. This is not north or district orientation."
  },
  "invariants": [
    "Two distinct blade/sail towers; shorter/slimmer left, taller/broader right in the declared comparison-front view.",
    "Left wrapping ivory ribbon and low stepped outer shoulder remain legible; right retains its sharper high crest and sweeping outer edge.",
    "Large visible open slot remains above the low podium and below the high bridge, with open sky above the bridge.",
    "One dominant elevated bridge body; no second independent floating bridge and no stacked public bridge route.",
    "One candidate enclosed gallery with visible glazed sides and amber interior; planted top remains distinct from the walking floor.",
    "Low arcade podium, curved blue glass, warm ivory fins, restrained warm metal accents and amber interiors.",
    "Inner terraces and planters support the pair's identity without vegetation concealing the tower edges or bridge connections.",
    "Vegetation remains a separate dressing scope; no pool, spa, restaurant, roof venue or new story program.",
    "No Crown Landmark central crown, giant central atrium or duplicated multi-prong silhouette.",
    "No numeric height, span, clearance, width, floor count, scale bar, north arrow or district-placement claim in concept imagery."
  ],
  "bounded_access_proposal": {
    "status": "candidate small enterable route; does not change the existing unselected Tier C starter",
    "route": [
      "left external arcade threshold",
      "left compact arrival lobby",
      "left core journey/interface",
      "left bridge landing",
      "enclosed bridge gallery",
      "right receiving landing with compact overlook bay",
      "return through the same gallery, left core and left lobby"
    ],
    "core_intent": "Study one left core journey from the lobby to the bridge. Reserve one core per tower toward the inner/rear side in the overall concept; the right core and additional egress remain future geometric/technical reservations, not a second interior commitment. Proposed lift plus protected stair continuity must be resolved by later plan/section and engineering review; no measured core fit or working lift is claimed.",
    "spaces_to_study": [
      "one left compact arrival lobby",
      "left core approach and bridge landing",
      "one crossing gallery",
      "right receiving landing with small integral overlook"
    ],
    "thresholds": "Maintain a clear continuous public route with same-route return. Controlled doors separate unmodeled tower floors and staff/service zones. Both exterior tower thresholds may be visible; a visible right threshold does not imply a developed right lobby. Lift/stair, door and safe egress behavior remain test requirements.",
    "viewpoint": "Small bay within the right receiving landing/gallery edge; no separate destination room or roof terrace.",
    "garden_access": "nonplayable planted roof; not counted as a second accessible level",
    "conditional_future_expansion": [
      "right arrival lobby interior",
      "right core interior journey or through-route exit",
      "playable garden route only after explicit scope selection"
    ],
    "deferred_or_excluded": [
      "right arrival lobby interior and right core journey",
      "typical office floors",
      "residential units",
      "full tower interiors",
      "all intermediate lift stops and floor corridors",
      "roof pavilion interiors",
      "bridge-roof garden gameplay",
      "pool and shade-sail amenity deck",
      "restaurants or retail fit-outs",
      "basements and parking",
      "plant rooms and service rooms beyond interface reservations",
      "Crown Landmark council/diplomacy rooms",
      "named story rooms"
    ],
    "room_and_level_ids": "diagram labels are functional placeholders; no issued room schedule, metric floor schedule or authoritative level IDs are created"
  },
  "alternatives_not_recommended_for_this_pass": [
    {
      "id": "A1",
      "alternative": "Literal close-render two-deck garden/pool bridge with two major spans",
      "reason": "Conflicts with the catalog's slim single connection and adds a separate amenity route, level/egress obligations and planting/pool scope before basic fit is known."
    },
    {
      "id": "A2",
      "alternative": "Near-equal or mirrored tower pair",
      "reason": "Loses the catalog's named asymmetric identity; cropped perspective does not authorize the change."
    },
    {
      "id": "A3",
      "alternative": "Bare thin exterior bridge with no enclosed route",
      "reason": "Could preserve the card's silhouette, but does not provide the selected sheltered lobby-to-bridge route or carry the useful close-render material experience. Retain as a fallback if H1 cannot fit."
    },
    {
      "id": "A4",
      "alternative": "Treat generated Concept A as the geometry master",
      "reason": "Its geometry has no authored metric model or saved cameras; promoting it would compound generated drift."
    },
    {
      "id": "A5",
      "alternative": "Copy Crown Landmark entrance or crown onto the gap",
      "reason": "Erases the Split Complex silhouette and uses another asset's reference beyond its material/quality role."
    },
    {
      "id": "A6",
      "alternative": "Expand immediately to full Tier C office/residential floors",
      "reason": "The starter proposes these kits but selects none; a bounded lobby/gallery route must establish useful relationships first."
    },
    {
      "id": "A7",
      "alternative": "Develop both lobbies and a complete two-core through-route in R01",
      "reason": "The source program proposes paired lobbies, but the first selected concept journey needs one arrival, crossing and receiving landing only. Reserve the far core/egress relationship without committing a second interior lobby."
    }
  ],
  "image_brief": {
    "global": "Architectural concept study of PI-BLD-0002-V01 Split Complex. Use S1 for complete massing, S2 for local facade/planting/bridge finish, and S3 only for finish quality and amber lighting. H1 is an authored recommendation, not a transcription of a resolved source. Neutral presentation background and consistent material family; no placed skyline.",
    "exterior_master": "Full building in one readable open-gap three-quarter view, both tower tips and the complete low arcade base visible. Shorter/slimmer left blade with wrapping ivory ribbon and stepped outer shoulder; taller/broader right sail with sharper crest and sweeping outer edge. Large central slot. One compact high bridge body with enclosed blue-glazed gallery, warm interior, curved ivory underside and modest planted roof. Ground passage stays open. No extra upper public deck, pool, Landmark crown or hidden cropped base.",
    "bridge_detail": "Show both actual-looking tower-side landing interfaces in the same view, one level walking surface inside a glazed gallery, a shallow planted roof above, warm ivory haunches below and no second crossing. Include the short landing vestibules and retain the empty slot beneath. Reveal enough glass that an enclosed route reads clearly. No floor numbers or metric labels.",
    "lobby_route": "Compact amber-lit arrival lobby under the Split Complex arcade, warm ivory arch pier, blue glazing, restrained warm metal, clear entrance to core approach. Use simple integrated light bands, modest seating outside the route, and a legible public path. Do not import Crown Landmark's multi-storey central portal, crown ribs or chandelier as a new identity.",
    "landing_viewpoint": "A small widening of the right receiving landing at the end of the same bridge gallery, with a clear same-route return, one restrained bench or guardrail-side pause area and neutral sky beyond the glazing. It is not an added lounge, restaurant, roof terrace or doorway to an authored right-tower interior.",
    "review_checks": [
      "correct left/right asymmetry",
      "both blade identities preserved",
      "complete open slot",
      "one accessible bridge band",
      "enclosed gallery readable",
      "garden roof not a second route",
      "landing thresholds clear",
      "low base and open ground passage",
      "same finish family",
      "no metric or placement claims"
    ],
    "label": "CONCEPT / RECOMMENDED H1 / NOT TO SCALE",
    "provenance_requirement": "The actual image operator records source images, method/tool, resulting image path/hash and qualitative differences. No authored model, saved physical cameras or metric overlay evidence are supplied by this decision record."
  },
  "outstanding_fit_and_placement": [
    {
      "topic": "Creator design/scope selection",
      "owner": "Legend",
      "required_evidence": "Review H1 images and bounded route; record selected authority, any changes, enterability and whether a garden route is desired later."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Massing and metric scale",
      "owner": "asset package author proposes; Legend selects scale",
      "required_evidence": "Author an asymmetric envelope and separate tower extents in the existing per-asset dimension contract. Establish a scale basis; no dimensions from perspective pixel ratios."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Two cores and floor compatibility",
      "owner": "layout/model author with Quik",
      "required_evidence": "Ground/bridge plans and vertical section through both reserved cores, with the left journey and far receiving landing developed to the selected scope; level schedule, future lift/stair continuity, landing openings and usable clearances. Matching bridge datum need not imply matching floor numbers; right core/lobby interiors remain deferred."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Bridge structure and landing fit",
      "owner": "layout/model author and technical reviewer",
      "required_evidence": "One future connection record for both ends; span, bearing zones, movement, structure/fin intrusions, level walking surface, headroom and roof build-up; prove compact H1 body can contain the route."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Access and egress",
      "owner": "layout author and Quik; design review by Legend",
      "required_evidence": "Continuous candidate public route, door operation, protected routes and lift/stair relationships; later real collision, character/camera and traversal evidence. A diagram is not egress approval."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Podium and entrance",
      "owner": "asset package author",
      "required_evidence": "Resolve depth, central open passage, continuous arcade edge, separate lobby thresholds and core approach in authored plan and section; verify furniture and door clearances."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Placement and external view",
      "owner": "Legend with district/layout author",
      "required_evidence": "Selected parcel, shared metric frame, front/north convention, ground datum, access interfaces and model-derived window views. No location inferred from the close render background."
    },
    {
      "topic": "Engine and production release",
      "owner": "Quik with package reviewers",
      "required_evidence": "Pilot feedback, actual versions, measured model/import, collision/navigation, materials and performance plus scoped creator/technical review. Foundation hold is not released by H1."
    }
  ],
  "dimension_values": null,
  "measured_layout": null,
  "model_revision": null,
  "saved_cameras": [],
  "metric_comparison_evidence": null
}
